Home » Finding Truth—Fearless Sifting and Winnowing
Home » Finding Truth—Fearless Sifting and Winnowing
In 1894, the University of Wisconsin Board of Regents investigated an economics professor. The Wisconsin Superintendent of Public Instruction, a Board member, had vigorously and publicly condemned the professor’s teaching. The Board of Regents exonerated the professor. Their famous decision was powerful statement supporting academic freedom of inquiry.
They stated that the University “should ever encourage that continual and fearless sifting and winnowing by which alone the truth can be found.” They expressed an unwavering commitment to seeking the truth. But they also showed a deep understanding of how to find truth.
Seeking truth is essential for verifying the principles to live by. The challenge is how to go about “sifting and winnowing.” We must always test the truth of what we learn regardless of its source. Many times, I have uncritically accepted something I read, only later to discover my error.
I started out hoping for certainty. What I found instead were ways to feel confident in what I held to be true while recognizing there will always be new information and that I may have to change my mind.
How can we separate what is true from what is false? How can we avoid following ideas and principles that don’t work? The field of moral philosophy and ethics is not a hard science with a history of repeatable experiments, double-blind studies, and reliable predictions. There are no mathematical equations for how to live.
The way to get closer to the truth is simple. It is a rigorous application of reason and evidence. After first understanding what truth means, I have tried to follow the approach used by many philosophers since Aristotle. Start with reason as the primary tool. Then test the result by looking for evidence that it works. This approach gives me confidence that what I know is true to the best of my ability at this moment.
It is common to see truth as a binary; something is true or false. I struggled with this idea as I sought solid principles to live by. I learned the truth is not that simple, and seeking unalterable truths can be disappointing, especially regarding humans.
There is an important distinction between truth and what we think is true. This is clearest in the physical sciences. Matter and energy follow immutable rules. Science is our attempt to get at those rules or truths. But it is always just the best that can be done with what we know. What we consider scientific truths, the laws of gravity for example, are the best explanation of how the physical world works. It is limited by what we know and can know. Scientific progress occurs as new theories and evidence provide better explanations of what we observe. Science is never “settled” as some argue. It is constantly improving. We can never say we have arrived at immutable truth. Einstein’s work on gravity, for example, did a better job predicting the orbits of planets compared to Newton’s “Laws of Gravity,” which were considered the truth for centuries.
This same distinction exists for the pursuit of truths related to how to live. What we know and believe is true is only the best we can do today. There will always be new ideas and new data that can help us get closer to the truth. As with the physical sciences, we should never assume we have arrived at an unchanging truth.
For example, what we consider true about human nature today is very different from our understanding a millennia ago. Human nature has not changed, but our understanding of what is true about human nature changed considerably. The distinction between an underlying truth and what we believe is true is common to both fields of inquiry.
But there is one critical difference between the pursuit of truth in the physical sciences and the truth about how people should best live. In hard sciences there is no judgment about what should be. The physical sciences are focused solely on what is. For truths about how to live, there is a human value judgment about what should be. That difference adds complexity and uncertainty even though applying intellectual rigor and evidence is needed for both.
These ideas about the nature of truth eluded me for some time. I like the idea of truth being fixed. I wanted to learn something and then not have to unlearn it. But I have come to appreciate that what we know and consider true now can change as we develop better theories and gather new evidence. I have also come to accept that when considering how to live well, there is invariably human judgment involved, particularly when defining the ends to be achieved. It is still important to pursue truth; it is just a little messier than pursuing truth about how subatomic particles interact.
We should be humble about what we know and what we can know in seeking truth in both fields of knowledge. Our ability to reason, measure, gather data, and test ideas, our best tools for pursuing truth, have limits. The best scientists are humble and understand the difficulties in finding truth. They seek open inquiry because that advances knowledge and furthers the understanding of truth.
This widely cited quote from Richard Feynman, a famous physicist, states the perspective well.
“There is no harm in doubt and skepticism, for it is through such doubt that new discoveries are made. We are never absolutely right. We can only be sure we are wrong if someone else shows it. That’s the essence of science: to welcome the proof that we are wrong.”
The process for finding truth in other fields (e.g., ethics, moral and political philosophy) has much in common with pursuing truth in the physical sciences. We can build on a body of knowledge and wisdom developed over thousands of years. It is not a blank slate. Then, like science, we can progress toward the truth using reason, intellectual rigor, and evidence.
The idea that our understanding of what is true can change with better thinking and evidence can be uncomfortable. Living would be simpler if we could simply jump to the underlying truth, by passing the messy discovery process. But that hope clashes with reality. Centuries of progress in all fields of knowledge show our understanding of truth can be challenged, reinforced, discredited, and replaced.
I admit to sidestepping some important questions about reality. I assume what we perceive is real, even if our perception is imperfect. Alternative views of reality are interesting, but they distract from the practical process of gaining knowledge to improve our lives. My world seems real enough to me. I have no hard evidence to the contrary. I may live in the Matrix, but I believe I am not.
After understanding and accepting the nature of truth, the job now is applying reason and evidence to sorting out what to believe and what to discard. I start with reason.
There is no more powerful tool for discovering truth than logic and reason. That is a great contribution of the Enlightenment. We could set aside superstition, myth, and divine revelation and instead apply observation, reason, and data to get at the truth.
Using reason to determine truth is a simple idea but hard to do. Our power of reason is limited. Emotions can cloud reason. Rigorous rules of logic are not always intuitive. And evidence can be unreliable.
But there are several ways to use reason in pursuing truth. Here are a few I find useful.
In mid-life, when I got more serious about my search for knowledge, I took a college course on logic. I learned how to reason better and how to recognize errors in reasoning. This provided better tools for evaluating the truth of statements and ideas.
The principles of a logical argument form the foundation. There are different forms of argument, such as deductive and inductive reasoning. Clarity and solid premises are also critical to sound reasoning.
Equally helpful to me was learning to spot logical fallacies. I find this most practical when interacting with others. People often tell us how to be happy. Their arguments may sound plausible but regularly contain basic reasoning mistakes. Errors such as false equivalency, false dilemmas, and straw man arguments are common. Arguments with internal contradictions are another sign of weak reasoning.
A simple reasoning tool I use frequently comes from Ayn Rand, a vigorous proponent of reason. She often advised people to “Check your premises.” The truth of an argument rests on its assumptions. False or highly questionable assumptions undermine arguments. Every day I encounter arguments based on false assumptions. I also make poor assumptions in my reasoning. For example, I based some beliefs on false assumptions about human nature. I had a lot of rethinking to do when I realized my error.
Checking premises is a good way to uncover biases. We all have biases. Some are cultural. Some occur because of the way our brains process information. Recognizing bias is important in making sound logical arguments.
Another useful logic tool is the thought experiment, a common practice among philosophers. You start by imagining a world where you put your ideas into practice. Then, you imagine how those ideas would logically work and what the outcome would be.
John Rawls had a famous thought experiment where he suggested people imagine a world where they did not know their situation (e.g. wealthy or poor, male or female). Then imagine adopting a policy or practice and consider how they would react if they had this “veil of ignorance” perspective. Immanuel Kant, in his categorical imperative, asks people to test their moral principles by imagining whether they could logically will others by universal law to follow them.
For all its power, reasoning can only get you so far. Ideas need to be tested against evidence and experience. Many well-reasoned ideas fail when put into practice. There are too many ways for reason to fall short. And the world is extraordinarily complex. That is why verification or falsification using practice and evidence is so important.
The argument for experience in truth seeking is not new. Two leading American thinkers, William James and John Dewey, argued that the correctness of an idea depends in part on whether it works in practice. For truths about how to live, that means they lead to greater human thriving. But we can go further back to the ideas of Hume, Smith, and Aristotle. They all recognized the limits and weaknesses of reason and saw that theoretical knowledge derived by reason needed real-world verification.
One starts by simply asking if there is any evidence to support a statement. I’ve heard many forceful statements backed up by logical arguments for which there is simply no supporting evidence.
If there is evidence, how good or convincing is it? For example, is the evidence repeatable? Does an idea work consistently across different contexts and people? Is the evidence anecdotal or from a rigorous study? Is the statistical analysis appropriate, and are the results significant? Has correlation been confused with causation?
Skepticism is healthy when examining evidence used to support or refute statement. There is ample evidence of poorly done and biased studies. And there is ever the confirmation bias where we pay attention to what supports our beliefs and ignore contradictory evidence.
There are the uncomfortable situations where strong evidence supports an idea or principle but there is a weak understanding of why. We know the equations for quantum mechanics work while we do not know why. You can use an idea proven to work even though you don’t know precisely why it works.
Unintentionally, humans have been conducting experiments in living for tens of thousands of years. History and culture have captured the results. There is much useful evidence here that can support or refute our ideas. It takes more study to uncover it. But it can provide the evidence needed for deciding what works and what doesn’t. That is why I love reading history books.
An example illustrates the process I am suggesting. This is what I try to go through when I encounter a new idea or statement that may be useful.
I heard many times as a child: “Honesty is the best policy.” This meant that we should always tell the truth. Even if I did something wrong, it was better to be honest about it when caught.
This guidance seemed reasonable at first. But then I had doubts. Don’t people lie all the time? Some of the most powerful people in the world seem to lie constantly. Maybe telling the truth was only for boy scouts. Perhaps you had to lie to get along or to get ahead.
After considering the arguments for telling the truth, the logic seems strong. Honesty is a logical antecedent to cooperation. If you trust someone, it is easier to work together. A culture of honesty reduces the cost of verifying whether someone is lying. The assumption of honesty is a necessary foundation for justice and fairness.
Thought experiments support the proposition. Imagine if everyone frequently lied. Imagine how the activities of daily life would be different under those circumstances. Clearly, in a thought experiment, an honest world would be a far better place to live.
Are there moral conflicts and ambiguities? Yes. It is common to encounter situations where telling the truth may cause more harm than good or run counter to another moral principle. There are the rare extremes (e.g. lying to the Nazi’s about hiding a Jew) that can be set aside for practical purposes. More common questions are: Should we tell the truth that would devastate someone with no benefit? Should we answer truthfully a question which no one had a right to ask?
These examples do not negate the basic moral principle to tell the truth. They do highlight the need for more subtle moral reasoning as well as practical ways to escape the situation without lying or telling the truth. Sometimes there is no escaping the need to balance competing moral principles.
Is there sound evidence that it is better to be honest? There are empirical studies showing that people who are honest are happier. Countries with a culture of trust and honesty tend to have better economies and lower crime. While not conclusive, there is always the possibility of mistaking correlation with causation, the evidence adds to the confidence that this is a good moral principle.
Is honesty consistent with human experience throughout history? For thousands of years, honesty has been a virtue, incorporated into culture through laws, customs, religious instruction, and literature. The survival of honesty as a virtue over such a long time is not proof of its validity but suggests it deserves serious consideration.
Finally, does honesty seem to work in our own experience? I have lied and been lied to. I know honesty is much better.
In this simple example, logic and the preponderance of evidence support the validity or truth of the moral guidance to tell the truth. It is not perfect, and there can be rare exceptions. Other maxims may be harder to think through. But the process is the same. It is the best way I have found to get to the truth, or close enough to the truth, to be useful in living.
We can find the truth using reason and evidence. The process involves skepticism, humility, and persistence. I have accepted that our understanding of the truth is only the best we can do with our abilities and current knowledge. We should be open to changing our minds and improving our ideas as we learn.
Fortunately, there is solid logic and ample evidence supporting many truths needed for living well. Many have withstood the test of time and are accessible to anyone looking. Sometimes we may lose sight of what has been learned. And sometimes poor logic and faulty evidence may mislead us. But with persistence we will progress in discovering truth by fearless sifting and winnowing.