Home » Philosophy » My Search for a Moral Foundation
Home » Philosophy » My Search for a Moral Foundation
I experienced a profound crisis in my fifties. It did not involve career, marriage, or health. I was fortunate in those areas. For several reasons, I lost confidence in my moral reasoning and beliefs about right and wrong, good, and bad. The trend toward moral relativism unsettled me. Could much of what I believe be wrong? Then, several events caused further doubt about my moral foundation and, importantly, about whether what I believed was true. It was an emotional and intellectual crisis. It was a philosophical crisis, although I did not see it that way at the time.
A fundamental task for anyone seeking to live a good life is choosing a moral code to live by. Purpose and goals define where you want to go. But to get there you must know what “good” is. For me, it was not simply adopting a moral code. It was establishing a foundation for the rules I adopted so I knew why those rules should be followed.
There is no certain answer to this fundamental question. There are many theories, but all have weaknesses. However, I believe there is a solid basis for morality that withstands rigorous scrutiny and can work for most people.
Why is having a foundation for morality important? Is not simply having a moral code that feels right and seems to work enough? In many cases, it may be. However, I want a higher standard than merely believing or accepting guidance of an authority I trust. There had to be a better guide for moral decision-making than following the prescriptions of one tribe or another. I want to be confident in defending my moral choices and feel they are true enough to warrant sacrifice.
Having a foundation for morality is also necessary when dealing with complex moral questions where basic standards seem inadequate, or sometimes contradictory. In these cases, I need to go beyond broad moral guidelines and determine what actions are morally right in a specific situation. I need more rigor to decide right and wrong.
I have always had an innate sense of what is right and wrong. We are likely born with a basic moral framework. The experience of growing up refined these basic moral inclinations. Adult life experience added richer, and often painful, moral lessons. I have also read extensively about moral philosophy and the major schools, including virtue ethics, utilitarianism, and deontology.
But I continued to feel uneasy about whether I had a solid foundation for my beliefs. It is one thing to adopt a moral code. It is much more challenging to explain why your moral code is correct and better than the alternatives. I was not sure I could argue convincingly why I had chosen one set of moral rules over another. My ethical beliefs felt right, but could they withstand harsh scrutiny?
Moral relativism exacerbated my unease. I saw how moral codes could have their roots in a culture and even individual circumstances. But I rejected the idea that all cultures and their morals were equally good or justified. That seemed to be too fluid to be practical for making life choices. There were too many instances where I strongly disagreed with the moral codes of a particular culture. They could not all be equally effective in furthering happiness.
Furthermore, moral relativism makes it more difficult to find common ground between diverse cultures. A certain level of moral agreement is necessary for societies to function effectively together.
While I approach morality from a secular perspective, I found my core values frequently align with those whose morality is rooted in a belief in God. We arrived at our beliefs about right and wrong through different paths. Yet we arrived at about the same place. How could this be? Is there any way to explain this convergence?
My approach to moral foundation challenge has three parts. The first is to clearly define the purpose of having a moral code. For me, this is thriving, both as an individual and as a community.
Then I needed to adopt a basic method and processes for developing and testing rules for living. I settled on reason, applied rigorously and informed by evidence and experience, as the most effective and workable foundation for morality. As Nietzsche noted, the Enlightenment killed God, which eliminated a widely accepted basis for morality for many. But reason, the primary alternative, has its problems as a reliable arbiter of right and wrong. I sorted through various ideas to find an approach I found satisfactory and workable.
Finally, I needed a practical way to follow the moral rules I want to live by. This is the step where well-reasoned ideas encounter hard realities. Here I found that age-old approaches such as virtues and habits have much to offer.
I have long believed that human thriving should be a primary goal for living. There is a long history behind this idea, dating back to Aristotle.
It seems that morality should further human thriving or flourishing. I think that one of the most effective ways to evaluate moral decisions is to examine the impact or contribution of different choices on human flourishing. An action is good if there are convincing arguments and evidence that it promotes individual and collective human thriving. Can there be a moral code that is worth following that does not further human well-being?
A workable definition of well-being and human flourishing is necessary for this line of reasoning to work. If no one agrees on a practical definition of well-being, then this approach becomes meaningless, and moral choices are reduced to mere matters of personal preference.
In another essay, I lay out my definition of thriving in more detail. Simply stated, well-being applies to individuals and society. The individual and community perspectives need to be considered and balanced. Well-being includes physical and material conditions (health, shelter, food). Equally important is realizing human potential – living meaningful, fulfilling lives. All this is consistent with the views of many who have written on human happiness and thriving.
Furthering human thriving is the primary goal for our actions. But it is just the start in determining moral worth of our actions. It takes more than good intent and hope to act morally. The demanding work is finding the specific moral principles and the practical means needed to guide our actions.
There are two primary ways to justify rules for what is right and wrong. One is reason. The other is the will of God. Each has significant problems.
Traditionally, ethical codes came, directly or indirectly, from God. Different mechanisms may be at work in revealing the rules. For some, the direct word of God is conveyed through divine revelation. For others, the guidance on how to live is more complex but still grounded in a belief in God and a belief that God wants people to behave in certain ways. Gods’ guidance can be found in religious texts, teachings, and prayer. Regardless of the specific means for understanding God’s will, God is at the center of most religious moral systems.
There are several problems with the God centered approach. There is the question of whether God chose moral codes because they are good, or whether they are good because God chose them. Then there are the differing interpretations of God’s guidance. There can be significant uncertainty, within and between religions, about how God intends us to act. Different people using the same religious sources and methods can reach opposing moral conclusions. These religious interpretations have been substantial enough to cause physical conflict and war. Those differences feed my skepticism.
The alternative is to determine morality independently of God. Since the Enlightenment, science, reason, experience, and other methods have gained and perhaps surpassed the word of God in establishing rules and principles to live by. Different moral systems and schools of moral philosophy emerged to define and justify moral behavior.
These reason-based approaches also have problems. They, too, can produce different answers. No school has been able to establish the moral dominance once held by the major religions. Additionally, many of these schools of thought lack an effective means for communicating and implementing their ideas. The religious approach, at least, has churches and established documents such as the Bible. It is unclear to me how reason based moral systems teach new generations right from wrong without a formal, stable mechanism.
Moral relativism further confuses the search for a moral foundation. It, in effect, rejects both reason and God as a foundation. Morality is a product of culture and circumstance. Some moral relativists assert that there is no objective basis for morality. One set of values is no better than another. There is no basis for criticizing an ethical system or ascertaining its value when you deny any objective tests. A culturally determined moral code does not necessarily make it right.
The confusion caused by the weaknesses of these approaches is a social and individual problem. It is one of the negative consequences of the Enlightenment. It is hard to build social cohesion when people live by different rules. A lack of a widely held moral code erodes the trust and stability needed for people to work cooperatively. How can you trust your neighbor if you are unsure what moral values they have and how they will behave? Absent common fundamental values, only laws provide a standard set of rules. Laws generally address only major moral issues. Laws are difficult to enforce if not backed up by shared values.
Over time I have come to favor reason, informed by evidence from human experience, as a reliable and useful foundation for morality. I can vigorously defend a carefully selected system for moral reasoning and its practical application. There are weaknesses and criticisms, of course. But they are far fewer than those of its alternatives. It is an approach sufficient for finding common moral ground among diverse groups.
While I am an atheist, I take comfort in my reliance on reason from some theologians, such as St. Thomas Aquinas, who argue that people can arrive at moral codes through reason. Divine revelation is not necessary for basic morality, although it may be necessary for salvation. My pursuit of the best moral reasoning may work even though I do not believe in God.
A British philosopher, Derek Parfit (1942-2017), spent much of his career working on the question of the objective basis for morality. His book, “On What Matters,” is a modern classic. He argues that there is an objective basis for moral codes and that the truth of moral principles is discoverable through reason.
Parfit’s system supports human flourishing. This idea aligns closely with the rule-based consequentialism, where one considers the outcome of following specific moral rules. But even Kant, who tied morality to duty rather than consequence, saw happiness as a legitimate human goal. Following his moral rules indirectly supports flourishing. Happiness may not be the sole objective of a robust moral system, but it is certainly a critical component.
Parfit’s approach relies on applying three primary systems of morality reasoning:
His highly respected work recognizes that these basic schools of moral philosophy tend to converge on similar moral guidance. We progress toward moral truths by applying the reasoning in these approaches. We can have more confidence in a moral principle if the three approaches tend to agree on its truth. With convergence, reasonable people, dispassionately applying these well-developed systems for moral reasoning, will likely arrive at similar answers to moral questions.
I find Parfit’s approach and the idea of convergence powerful. It reflects my own experience of working through tough moral problems. Earlier in life, I found it hard to settle on one method, such as deontology, as my primary guide. Each system I studied had its appeal but also its flaws. By considering several approaches to moral reasoning, I made more progress in good moral decision making. I sometimes expand the systems I consider such as including the ideas on virtue from Aristotle and the Stoics.
Parfit also observes that the spiritually based morality of the Judeo-Christian religions tends to arrive at similar moral principles, although he does not argue that spirituality is an equally valid path to moral truth. The convergence suggests that many religious moral rules are inherently good, independent of God. If God wants us to follow them, it is because they are logically good, not simply because he says so. Parfit’s observation also matches my experience of arriving at, through reasoning, moral principles like those of my Christian friends.
It is easy to poke holes in any moral system by bringing up extreme examples. The existence of ethical dilemmas (e.g., the trolley problem) shows that any system has its limits. However, I am not aiming for an ironclad system or one that is unambiguous. We are humans and this is unrealistic. Nevertheless, as a foundational approach that is practical and works well most of the time, it seems to pass the test.
Adopting the moral framework I favor does not provide instant moral clarity. The world is exceptionally complex, and human reasoning can be flawed. Making difficult moral decisions is often challenging.
There are some simple rules we do not have to think hard about. We can act out of habit and instinct. Few question whether lying, stealing, and murder are wrong. However, even in these simple examples, there are situations requiring in-depth moral reasoning.
I have encountered many critical moral questions where there is no immediately apparent correct answer. These decisions involved applying several different moral principles. Often, there are tradeoffs. There is always uncertainty and a lack of knowledge. I yearn for straightforward, black-and-white rules that would simplify my decisions. That is not the world we live in. Making tough ethical decisions will often be messy and challenging regardless of one’s grounding in moral reasoning.
While there is still moral ambiguity and uncertainty, a reason-based moral system opens the door for learning and progress. Our environment is constantly changing, and we are rapidly gaining knowledge about the world and how it operates. Moral codes that further human flourishing must account for the environment in which people live.
A society existing in harsh conditions may put more emphasis on morals and values related to group loyalty and discipline. You cannot afford to have people not pulling their weight and sticking together. Societies in favorable environments with abundant resources may prioritize individual freedom over group cohesion.
Western cultural norms have evolved, often because of reasoned arguments. Slavery was once accepted as moral. It was considered natural even among the high-minded Greeks. The change over time in acceptable and unacceptable behavior between men and women could hardly be starker. The list of positive moral changes over the last several centuries is long.
These changes extend beyond merely social norms and politics. There are many examples of fundamental changes in the moral codes endorsed by organized religions. The Protestant Reformation introduced significant changes in the understanding of sin and the consequences for immoral behavior. Many religions have changed their moral codes regarding relations between men and women, homosexuality, and birth control. I believe many of these changes are driven by environmental circumstances. The environment changed, and the benefits of certain behaviors for individuals and society changed (some became less desirable, while others became more so), and secular and religious codes changed accordingly.
The complexity of moral reasoning and the effects of a changing environment can be unnerving. It can make moral decisions seem too fluid. But I am willing to pay that price to have the ability to learn and adapt. That is a big advantage of a moral system grounded in rigorous moral reasoning. It can improve with learning and experience while not being susceptible to whim and fashion.
I want to avoid certain forms of moral relativism. Descriptive relativism observes that morals vary between cultures. Normative relativists argue that we should tolerate cultural differences in morality. Individual relativists say that the values and morals of each culture are equally valid and that there is no objective basis for determining which culture’s morality is superior to another’s. Some take this idea to an extreme where anyone can formulate their equally valid moral code.
I accept that some moral codes are a product of culture. But just because a culture adopts a certain moral practice, does not necessarily make it good. There are many weaknesses in group behavior, in large part because of our tribal nature. People can coalesce around certain behaviors with no good reason. While there can be wisdom in crowds, there is also madness. There are many examples of cultures adopting moral behavior now widely considered wrong. The practice of sati where widows burned themselves to death is one example. Honor killing is another.
Moral relativism can make moral progress difficult. It is harder to conclude that one practice is better than another if the primary test is wide acceptance within that culture. Without more specific criteria, moral codes are hard to change. Adoption of different moral standards comes less through logical argument and evidence than through other, less rigorous means.
Another weakness of moral relativism in general is that it provides weak support the broad cooperation among and within societies. When each moral system is viewed as equal, the basis for agreement on common ethical practices is narrower. It is harder to create common moral ground which makes working together easier.
It can be easy to fall into relativistic thinking. One can start to think that because moral reasoning is messy and morals can change over time, deciding what is ethical is just a matter of personal preference. It has happened to me. For anything you want to do, you can find some culture that allows or condones it. Many times, I have heard the justification “In (some culture or country) this practice is allowed, so it is ok for me to do it.”
There is a related view that any activity between consenting adults is morally acceptable. This always struck me as the lowest possible bar for moral action. It assumes the ability to completely isolate the actions of consenting individuals from their impacts on others. I have found that rarely, if ever, occurs. People a simply too connected to each other in many ways.
Using reason to establish moral principles is an antidote to moral relativism. Parfit was adamant in his opposition to moral relativism. Rigorously applying reason and logic, starting with the three approaches he recommends, yields a more reliable determination of right and wrong. We can assess which moral codes are preferrable to others. It is not perfect and it does not offer absolutes. But it does provide the tools for reasonable people to work toward agreement.
I conclude with a few thoughts on how to apply moral reasoning in a practical way in daily life. Separating right from wrong and formulating the moral rules you want to live by is a lifelong pursuit. It requires practice and often humility, as you will sometimes get it wrong. But these steps seem to work for me.
A good moral code should work in practice, not just in theory. Does your moral code produce a society where you and others flourish? How strong is the logic and reasoning linking moral behavior and human thriving? Are your moral decisions consistent with virtue? These are all good questions to ask ourselves when making ethical choices.
There is no effortless way to moral clarity and a solid framework for ethics. But framing the issue as the rigorous application of reason and evidence makes the most sense to me. The goal of human flourishing helps focus the logic and evidence. There will always be moral dilemmas. But it is a strong alternative to the destructive versions of moral relativism. It can help one be more confident of moral decisions and help build a common moral framework with our community.
I occasionally think about my most important decisions involving moral principles and their practical application. In some cases, I will never know whether I made the right decision. Often consequences take years to become apparent. In my retrospective review, the decisions I feel most comfortable were those where I followed, consciously or not, the basic process outlined here. My decision making was strongest when thriving, broadly defined, was the goal, I used the best reasoning skills and ethical principles I had at the time, and I was practical in putting my decisions into action. I know more now and am more thorough and disciplined in making important decisions. But my history of what has worked, and what has not, leads me to believe I am on the right track.